Changing the Balance of Power.
This
chapter describes if students deserve the power of choosing and the
consequences of giving them that power. Also, in this chapter, we will answer the questions: What can one learn
from this? And, How teachers or future teachers
can apply that knowledge in a teaching situation?
First,
do students deserve to have the power of choice? Yes, as they take a great part
in the learning process. However, learners have only some say. They do not dominate the whole
classroom. According to the book “Learner-Centered Teaching: Five Key Changes
to Practice”, Chapter 4 (Weimer, 2013) between students
and the teacher. For example, the main aim of a reading class would be to read a
book, and usually, the book is given by the teacher (a controlled practice).
Students, therefore, will be demotivated to read because they must read something that
was previously selected by the teacher, not by them. If the teacher wants to guide learners to
read something, at least he or she should give them some power, like providing
book options for students to choose. That would change students' perspective
over reading and would make learning meaningful.
Second,
what would be the consequences of giving students some power in the classroom?
According to Jostens (2016) several positive
consequences one can find. For example, if students notice what they say
and think is important, they will participate more actively. Learners will
acquire knowledge not on the teacher's pace but theirs. Giving students more power
will foster learner
independence, they will investigate and learn not because the
teacher wanted them to do so but because they want to know what their potential
is, how far they can go. Besides, giving students a voice in the classroom will
improve the teacher-student relationship and the classroom environment since
the teacher will be a guide, monitor
and observer and only a controller
and feedback-provider when necessary.
To
conclude, what one can learn from this? The answer is really simple. To give a
voice to our students, they need to become independent learners. They need to
be involved in the decision making of the class. As a result, we will have more
motivated students, learners with a sense of control, and with less disruptive
behavior. That will improve the teacher-student relationship and the classroom
environment because for a teacher it would be a pleasure to work with students
who want to work and more importantly to learn. Now, How teachers can apply
this in a real classroom? One can share control in the classroom with these
tips.
- Allow students to be themselves. According to Willis & ETS (1997) in their journal Sharing Control in the Classroom, if a teacher allows his or her students to be themselves he or she will gain a more collaborative relationship, avoiding at the same time major battles. But always with a limit.
- Let students offer their criteria in the elaboration of the curriculum. That will reduce the teacher’s amount of time doing something that may or may not work in the future when applied. And also, students will have the opportunity to set their own goals, what they can achieve during the learning process.
For
further reading:
Weimer, M. (2013). Learner-Centered Teaching : Five Key
Changes to Practice (2nd ed.). John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated.
Retrieved from https://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/uta-ebooks/reader.action?docID=1119448&ppg=162
Jostens. (2016). Giving students a voice in the classroom. Educational Leadership, 11. Retrieved from https://www.jostensrenaissance.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/NovemberSearchInstitute-Voice.pdf
Willis, S., & ETS. (1997). Sharing Control in the
Classroom, 1. Retrieved from
https://www.ets.org/s/efolio/pdf/Sharing_Control_Classroom.pdf